Take Action Against False Animal Cruelty Allegations

Target: Dave Yost, Attorney General of Ohio

Goal: Ensure accountability for individuals falsely reporting animal cruelty

In an alarming development, a growing trend of false allegations of animal cruelty has come to light, putting undue strain on the resources dedicated to protecting animals in need. The phenomenon, characterized by baseless reports against individuals, has escalated to a troubling frequency, diverting attention and vital resources away from actual cases of distress and maltreatment. Jane MacMurchy, the executive director of Animal Charity of Ohio, highlights the gravity of the situation, with false alarm calls now occurring multiple times daily, starkly detracting from the organization’s capacity to aid genuinely abused animals.

These spurious claims, often allegedly motivated by personal vendettas rather than factual instances of wrongdoing, not only burden the accused but also significantly hamper law enforcement and animal protection agencies. Valuable time and effort are squandered on investigating unfounded accusations, and, more critically, animals genuinely in peril are left waiting longer for the help they desperately need. This misuse of the reporting system erodes the very foundation of trust and efficiency crucial to animal welfare efforts.

The necessity for a robust legal framework to penalize those who knowingly lodge false reports of animal cruelty cannot be overstated. Such measures would serve as a deterrent against the misuse of animal protection mechanisms, ensuring that resources are judiciously allocated to cases where animals are truly at risk. Demand the implementation of stringent legal penalties for the deliberate misreporting of animal cruelty, safeguarding the integrity of animal welfare initiatives and ensuring that help reaches those truly in need.


Dear Attorney General Dave Yost,

The troubling rise in false reports of animal cruelty represents a significant challenge to the integrity and efficacy of animal welfare efforts. These unfounded allegations, as highlighted by Jane MacMurchy of Animal Charity of Ohio, not only misdirect crucial resources but also diminish the capacity of dedicated agencies to respond to genuine cases of abuse and neglect. The situation demands urgent attention and action to preserve the sanctity of animal welfare operations.

The detrimental impact of these false alarms extends beyond the immediate inconvenience to the accused; it fundamentally undermines the trust upon which the system of reporting and responding to animal cruelty is built. Law enforcement and animal welfare organizations are forced to divert their limited resources to address these claims, consequently delaying the provision of aid to animals truly in need. This misallocation of resources and efforts compromises the welfare of vulnerable animals and strains the system designed to protect them.

In light of these challenges, we respectfully urge you to enact and enforce laws that specifically target and penalize the act of knowingly making false allegations of animal cruelty. Such legal measures would deter individuals from abusing the reporting system and ensure that resources are concentrated on investigating and mitigating genuine cases of animal abuse. By holding accountable those who misuse the system, we can better protect the welfare of animals and uphold the integrity of animal protection efforts.


[Your Name Here]

Photo credit: Théo Paul

One Comment

  1. Our entire society is beyond saving. To falsely accuse someone of something so deplorable as animal cruelty needs to be investigated and if found to be a lie then the penalty needs to be extremely high! We need truth, not lies. We need eithics a code of rights and wrongs. We need principles which are too often completely forgotten in the world today. We need to have respect for ourselves in order to have and apply respect for others. Do you want to be right or do you want to be happy? Everyone says, falsely, they want to be happy but they only want to be right. To be right is misery but to be happy means you forgive people and then there is only happiness for you! It’s the better choice!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


651 Signatures

  • Rose Elcsics
  • Caleb Crawford
  • Elias Deeb
  • Mary & Roger Stephens
  • Kathleen Vadnais
  • Cynthia Kelley
  • James R Brown
  • judith worrall
  • Helene Singer
  • Margaret Durbas
1 of 65123...65
Skip to toolbar