Target: Scott D. McNamara, District Attorney of Oneida County, New York
Goal: Seek the maximum lawful sentence, restitution, and a lifelong ban on animal ownership for the defendant who allegedly beat a cat named Eva, causing significant suffering.
Witnesses and police reports describe a disturbing video in which a man is seen striking a cat named Eva. According to local coverage, Eva was later placed in foster care and is recovering, while the accused faces charges that include aggravated cruelty to animals and failing to provide sustenance. Supporters outside court have called the act malicious and intentional, urging meaningful consequences that reflect the severity of the alleged abuse.
Charging documents and press statements indicate multiple cruelty-related counts. Community members say this was not a mishap but a deliberate act recorded on video, which amplifies public concern. Animal-welfare advocates warn that such violent conduct toward animals can correlate with broader risks to public safety, making accountability and prevention essential.
Appropriate accountability in this case would protect animals and deter future harm. Prosecutors should pursue the strongest penalties allowed, alongside a court-ordered lifetime prohibition on owning, keeping, or residing with animals, mandatory counseling, and restitution for Eva’s care. These measures, if imposed, would serve justice while helping prevent further cruelty.
PETITION LETTER:
District Attorney McNamara,
We are writing regarding the case involving Eva the cat, where video evidence allegedly depicts a man striking her and causing severe distress. He now faces animal-cruelty charges. This alleged intentional act, captured on video, has shaken the community and underscores the need for firm action.
We respectfully urge your office to pursue the maximum lawful penalties. In addition, please seek a lifetime ban on owning, possessing, or residing with animals, court-ordered counseling or anger-management treatment, and full restitution for veterinary and foster-care costs. These remedies are warranted given the alleged deliberate nature of the conduct and the risks it poses to vulnerable animals.
Strong prosecution in this matter would send a clear message that cruelty will be met with serious consequences, helping protect animals across Oneida County. Thank you for prioritizing justice and prevention in this case.
Sincerely,
[Your Name Here]
Photo credit: André Karwath aka Aka
