Sign the Petition

Target: Maui County Government
Goal: Implement stricter penalties for animal cruelty offenses to ensure justice for victims like Eddie the pig.
The recent sentencing of Jayden Jarnesky-Magana for the theft and brutal killing of a beloved pet pig named Eddie has left the community in outrage. Sentenced to merely one night in jail and four years of probation, Jarnesky-Magana reportedly entered Eddie into a feral pig hunting competition after stealing him from Kitty Charm Farm, where he had found refuge. This incident, apparently characterized by unimaginable cruelty and the exploitation of a vulnerable animal, raises serious concerns about the judicial system’s commitment to holding perpetrators of animal abuse accountable.
The details of the case are truly alarming. Eddie, a 250-pound male pig, was allegedly taken from a sanctuary dedicated to providing a safe haven for animals in need, reflecting a betrayal of trust. The sanctuary’s founder, Sarah Haynes, described the profound impact of losing Eddie, who had been previously abused and adopted in hopes of giving him a better life. Instead, he was apparently subjected to a heinous act that, instead of facing appropriate penalties, resulted in an inconceivably lenient sentence for his alleged killer.
This case underscores the urgent need for comprehensive reform in animal protection laws in Hawaii. Such minimal consequences for acts of cruelty not only undermine justice for the suffering endured by animals like Eddie but also risk creating a culture where such acts are trivialized. Stricter penalties must be enforced to deter potential offenders and reaffirm the message that animal cruelty will not be tolerated. Demanding a reevaluation of sentencing guidelines for animal abuse cases is essential to ensure justice and protection for vulnerable animals in our communities.
PETITION LETTER:
Dear Maui County Government,
The recent case involving Jayden Jarnesky-Magana and the alleged theft and killing of Eddie the pig has sparked an unprecedented outcry from animal advocates and members of the community. The sentence of one night in jail and four years of probation for such a brutal act of alleged cruelty is not only shocking but appears to send a troubling message about the judicial system’s stance on animal welfare. It appears Eddie’s life was stolen and that he suffered immensely due to the actions of individuals who exploited him for a monetary prize.
The details of Eddie’s tragic story are heart-wrenching. Rescued from a life of abuse, he was living at Kitty Charm Farm, a sanctuary dedicated to his well-being. Instead of receiving the love and safety he deserved, he was apparently subjected to a violent death for a hunting competition, reinforcing the need for harsher consequences for those who commit such egregious acts. The community’s response, including demonstrations outside the courthouse, highlights the collective frustration over the leniency shown towards animal cruelty cases.
We urge you to act to make sure future cases like this are treated with the seriousness they deserve. Stricter penalties are crucial in fostering a societal understanding that such behavior is unacceptable. The tragic fate of Eddie demands justice, and it is imperative to establish a precedent that acknowledges the severity of these crimes.
Sincerely,
[Your Name Here]
Photo credit: Pixabay
My heart goes out to the owners of this innocent and loved pig!!! The owner saw on social media what they did to this beautiful pig!!!
https://www.live5news.com/2025/04/17/no-excuse-man-sentenced-killing-beloved-pet-pig-during-hunting-contest/
That is a DISGRACE!
How DARE those assholes care more about the damn HUNTING contest – that is a travesty too!
And that is NOT a “good kid.” That is a piece of shit.
This is why I am 100% for vigilante justice. None of these fucking judges ever do anything to these garbage humans.
It must have been traumatic and devastating for them to see what had been done to their beautiful porcine companion. Shoot they guy in the knees and drop him off in the middle of a desert.
And, poor Eddie. He just wanted to give and receive love. Those judging this case should think of what he endured at the hands of this piece of dreck.
If it were up to me, I would encourage all those outraged at the evil brute who stole and had this pet pig violently murdered, to find the guy who did this and take revenge. It is what I would want to do. The guy is a nasty, cruel, wicked brute, and deserves extermination. It would keep other innocent animals safe from him!
HERE WE GO AGAIN!!!THIS POOR INNOCENT BEAUTIFUL LITTLE PIG LEFT IN THE HANDS OF THIS ABHORRENT MONSTER!!
THIS ISN’T JUSTICE ITS LAUGHABLE WHAT A JOKE!!! THE SO CALLED AUTHORITIES AND TGE JUSTICE SYSTEM STINKS AND NEED TO GET THEIR ACT TOGETHER!!WHOSE SIDE ARE THEY ON DEFINITELY NOT POOR PIGGYS.