Applaud Court for Taking a Stand Against Animal Cruelty

ThinDog_PublicDomainPictures

Target: Thomas A. Balmer, Chief Justice, Oregon Supreme Court

Goal: Thank court for sending the message that animals are not property to use an abuse, and encourage them to consider the sentience of animals in future cases.

A landmark decision has been made by the Supreme Court of the state of Oregon regarding the treatment of animals. The case dealt specifically with one animal, a dog named Juno who was allegedly mistreated and starved by his owner, and later seized by law enforcement.

Juno’s sick and emaciated state required veterinarians to process his blood work to decide if he had been deliberately starved. In an effort to avoid ramifications for mistreating her dog, Juno’s owner argued that the dog was a piece of property and thus the blood draw was an “unreasonable search” of her property under Oregon law. While this rationale may sound farfetched, the dog’s owner was not too far off her mark. By law animals, even pets, are considered property of their guardians; in many cases no different than a laptop or a car.

However, thanks in part to the efforts of the Animal Legal Defense Fund (ALDF), the Court was persuaded away from seeing animals in this light while hearing the case. ALDF argued that animals should not be considered mere property, as it is clear they are sentient beings who experience emotions and pain. Juno was not just a piece of this woman’s property, but a thinking, feeling animal who had been horribly mistreated.

The Court’s decision to uphold charges against Juno’s owner is a win for not only this dog, but all animals. By refusing to reduce Juno to a mere “container to be searched,” the Court took a stand against animal cruelty and a progressive step towards a new legal distinction for animals. It’s high time the legal system recognize that animals are not ours to torment. Applaud the Court for making this landmark decision and encourage them to uphold it in future animal cruelty cases.

PETITION LETTER:

Dear Chief Justice Balmer,

I was shocked to hear about the case of Juno, a dog who had reportedly been abused and starved by his owner. Juno was so emaciated that he was seized by law enforcement and placed in veterinary care, where they drew his blood to determine why he was so thin. In an attempt to avoid cruelty charges for allegedly mistreating her dog, Juno’s owner insisted these tests were an “unlawful search” of her property, her property being Juno.

It comes as a shock to many to hear pets referred to as mere property. But in Oregon, as well as in the rest of the country and most of the world, animals are barely different from a car or table in the eyes of the law. There are very obvious ethical problems with classifying animals as property. Animals, especially intelligent sentient ones like cats and dogs, are thinking, feeling beings who experience pain and emotions.

Your decision to deny the owner’s argument and uphold cruelty charges for Juno sends a message that animals are not just pieces of mere property. I would like to thank you and the rest of the Supreme Court of Oregon for making this progressive decision, and encourage you to consider the sentience of animals in future cruelty cases.

Sincerely,

[Your Name Here]

Photo Credit: Public Domain Pictures

Sign the Petition

  • Only your name will be displayed. By signing, you accept our terms and may receive updates on this and related causes.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
FacebookCare2 NewsTwitterEmailShare

9 Comments

  1. Yeah!!! now at election time please remember how important it is to google the persons you are going to vote for for any office. Just google the name and their record on animal welfare issues. See how they voted!

  2. SUZANNED. says:

    THIS BEAST OF A NOTHING SHOULD NEVER , NEVER BE ALLOWED TO HAVE ANY INNOCENT ANIMAL YOU OWN THE CLOTHES ON YOUR BACK, THE PLACE YOU LIVE IN, THE CAR YOU DRIVE. YOU MAY OWN YOUR DOG, BUT THE DOG IS A LIVING BREATHING CREATURE. YOU CLOTHES, ABUSE THEM INSTEAD YOUR COMPANION YOU SICK IDIOT.

  3. This lady should stop spending money and time defending herself. Her money would be better spent on mental services for herself. She is mentally ill. Sick violent mentally ill people abuse and starve vulnerable creatures. Print her name, we deserves to be warned and aware of the criminally I’ll in the community! A tattoo on the forehead would be best, that would make it easy to spot trouble, because that’s all these sickos are!! Trouble and suffering and stupidity!

  4. Cynthia Mattera says:

    Dear Chief Justice Balmer, you are a good man!!! Its about time the law is in favor of animals, and will protect them. Thank you so very much for speaking up for the voiceless!!!

  5. David Lavery says:

    Thank goodness those good people speak for animals , they do deserve rights and abusers do deserve to suffer.

  6. Thomas A. Balmer, Chief Justice, Oregon Supreme Court is a HERO. Thank you so much!

  7. Janelle Bakey Janelle Bakey says:

    proud of the state i live in for making huge strides like this!

  8. Alice Cheang says:

    Yes, the world needs more leaders like Chief Justice Balmer!! Thank you Chief!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Comments

comments

1637 Signatures

  • Georgia Benyk
  • Donna Griffin
  • Katherine Beckley
  • Bodil Andreasen
  • Margaret McGullam
  • Audrey Connor
  • Kimberly Heath
  • Janet Bradley
  • Janine Vinton
  • Cami Winikoff
1 of 164123...164
Skip to toolbar